tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8249597570984018989.post1081977445659433445..comments2023-10-25T06:11:31.411-06:00Comments on The Historyscoper's Islam Watch Blog: Oliver Stone: 'Jewish-Dominated Media' Prevents Hitler from Being Portrayed 'in Context*Historyscoperhttp://www.blogger.com/profile/13821885034444628101noreply@blogger.comBlogger2125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8249597570984018989.post-55367177499170030332010-08-02T09:52:24.906-06:002010-08-02T09:52:24.906-06:00I don't think Zionists overplayed their hand w...I don't think Zionists overplayed their hand when lobbying for a home land. When lobbying for a home land one is obligated to play every card available.<br /><br />That said, comparing Hitler's percentage body count to prove he mistreated Jews worse than Slavs is pathetic. Hitler killed about 6M jews and 25M slavs, the % is higher for Jews, only because he had more time to finish what he started with Jews and the Slavs were more numerous, better equipped and fought back harder. In point of fact, were it not for the Russian Slavs, Hitler would have won, and there would be no Jewish homeland, nor any Jews. This whole my victimization is worse than your victimization game is sad.<br /><br />The US did nothing to Jewry that would obligate them to protect and defend Israel. Only Israel is obligated to protect and defend Israel.<br /><br />Palestinians have a right to fight their expulsion from their home land and they certainly are owed payment for land forcibly taken. However, the State of Israel is a fact and they should recognize that their best interests are served in surrendering Jerusalem and Israel should get all of its illegal settlements out of the occupied territories.<br /><br />As for historic claims, I call bullshit. Historic claims have no merit. If you follow that logic, the whole of Europe needs to go back to the Celts and Goths and Visigoths and the Romans and the US has to give back Texas, New Mexico, Nevada, Arizona and California to Mexico, and they, in turn, to Spain, and then the Aztecs and so on and on and on.<br /><br />Israel has a right to exist because the UN said they did. Period. It isn't who had it first, it's who has it now.JJ from AZhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/18188362642095356029noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8249597570984018989.post-50986278582695704242010-07-27T14:25:42.324-06:002010-07-27T14:25:42.324-06:00My reply:
Stone might be right that after WWII wa...My reply:<br /><br />Stone might be right that after WWII was over, the Zionists overplayed their victim status to get more sympathy and reparations for their new Jewish state of Israel, but he's all wet in comparing what Hitler did to the Russians to what he did to the Jews, the proportions aren't nearly equal, and the total utter degradation of Jewish people they fostered makes the Nazis unfit to return. Maybe it wasn't 6 million but some lower number, but even if it was only 60 thousand what the Nazis did was unforgivable, and combined with 2K years of anti-Semitism against the Jewish people they have a right to their Jewish homeland and the U.S. must support them in it no matter how much pressure Arabs mount. Instead of fostering anti-Semitism, Palestinians might think about working with fellow Arabs to resettle in some of their vast territories and leave poor outnumbered surrounded Israel alone. Scope Jerusalem's history back 3,000 years and see why the Jews have the only historic right to the area, with or without holy books and their claims, and despite the U.N., Arab propaganda, even the Nazis.<br /><br />http://historyscoper.com/tlwjerusalem.htmlHistoryscoperhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/13821885034444628101noreply@blogger.com